Author: Scott Horton

Scott has been practicing Labor & Employment law in New York for almost 20 years. He has represented over 400 employers and authored 100s of articles and presentations and wrote the book New York Management Law: The Practical Guide to Employment Law for Business Owners and Managers. Nothing on this blog can be considered legal advice. If you want legal advice, you need to retain an attorney.

Top Posts of 2019

Top Posts of 2019

As the year ends, we again review the most viewed New York Management Law Blog posts from this year. Did you miss any of the top posts of 2019?

These posts reflect some topics that most interested New York employers in 2019. Do they also suggest what will be top of mind in 2020?

Curious about last year? Click to see what posts made the list in 2018.

2020 New York Minimum Wage

Our annual post reminding employers of increases to both minimum wage and the salary threshold for overtime exemptions under state law remained a must-read.

Remember, these changes take effect on December 31, 2019, not January 1st. If you haven’t adjusted accordingly yet, now’s the time!

The required pay levels will continue to rise in the coming years. This post includes charts showing those planned increases.

Recovering Overpaid Wages in New York

Beyond addressing how much you have to pay them, New York also has strict rules about making deductions from employee compensation. Employers can withhold pay to recoup overpaid wages, but must satisfy detailed requirements to do so.

This post provides the basics of when and how employers can get their money back through payroll deductions. Don’t try it without this guidance. Even then, be cautious and seek professional assistance.

Readers were also quite interested in this more general review of the New York Wage Deduction Rules.

How Far Will New York Go?

2019 featured the extensive expansion of employee rights, and we expect more in 2020.

In addition to broader employment discrimination laws, New York imposed a statewide salary history ban. As of January 6, 2020, New York employers may not “seek, request, or require the wage or salary history from an applicant or current employee as a condition”:

  • to be interviewed,
  • of continuing to be considered for an offer of employment, or
  • of employment or promotion.

The State Legislature also passed legislation that would have permitted employees to use Paid Family Leave Benefits for bereavement leave. Governor Cuomo vetoed that law in 2019. But there are indications that the State will revisit the subject in 2020.

Workplace bullying was another item of notable interest among our readers. We wouldn’t be surprised to see New York add new protections in this area in the foreseeable future.

What’s Changing Under the FLSA?

The federal Fair Labor Standards Act governs minimum wage and overtime requirements throughout the United States.

In 2019, the U.S. Department of Labor finalized a rule that changes how some companies will calculate their employees’ overtime pay. The rule takes effect on January 15, 2020. It will generally act to decrease overtime rates.

The U.S. DOL also addressed who qualifies for exemptions from overtime pay in the first place. Beginning January 1, 2020, the weekly salary requirement for the FLSA administrative, executive, and professional exemptions will increase from $455 to $684. However, this probably won’t change much in New York, where the exemption threshold is already higher.

Employers Regain Control Over Company Email Use

As in recent years, the National Labor Relations Board has issued several significant decisions at year-end. Our readers have been most interested in this one about whether employees have the right to use company email for nonwork purposes.

For five years, most non-supervisory employees at private companies had that right. Now, most don’t.

Find out more about why the NLRB reinstated employer control over company property here.

Don’t Stop at the Top Posts of 2019!

I hope you find it helpful to look back at what happened last year, but you should also look forward. For some of the reasons stated above, and others, 2020 could be another big year in employment law. Please continue to follow the New York Management Law Blog for updates.

One great way to keep up with emerging topics in New York labor and employment law is to subscribe to our monthly email newsletter. If you want more frequent news and insights, be sure to follow us on LinkedIn!

See you in 2020!

Confidentiality in Workplace Investigations

NLRB Restores Confidentiality in Workplace Investigations

A December 16, 2019 NLRB decision reinstated employers’ discretion to maintain confidentiality in workplace investigations. In 2015 the federal Labor Board had found that employees’ rights to communicate with each other generally trumped company secrecy in this area. The new ruling allows investigatory confidentiality to be the default, rather than the exception.

Previous Standard

In 2015, an Obama-era NLRB panel with a Democrat majority held companies to the burden of demonstrating a specific need for confidentiality regarding a particular investigation. In other words, the default was the employers could not force employees to keep quiet about an ongoing internal inquiry.

Under the Banner Estrella Medical Center ruling, employers could only require confidentiality upon affirmative evidence that:

  • witnesses need protection;
  • evidence is in danger of destruction;
  • testimony is in danger of fabrication; or
  • there is a need to prevent a cover-up.

In that decision, the Board found that, absent these factors, employees’ rights under Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act outweighed company interests in preserving the integrity of an investigation. Section 7 of the NLRA protects employees who engage in concerted activity for their mutual aid and protection regarding terms and conditions of employment.

Concern with Lack of Confidentiality

A strenuous critique of the Banner Estrella Medical Center decision was that it was inconsistent with EEOC guidance encouraging confidentiality in workplace investigations. Specifically including investigations of sexual harassment, the EEOC has long emphasized that employer procedures for resolving internal complaints “should ensure confidentiality as much as possible. . . .”

Over the past few years, the EEOC and NLRB have attempted to reconcile their inconsistent stances. The new NLRB position eliminates the conflict between these federal agencies.

Changing the Presumption (Back)

The NLRB’s 3-1 decision in a case involving Unique Thrift Store once again permits employers to ask their employees to keep investigations confidential. They can do so as the default, without first evaluating prescribed criteria.

Unique Thrift Store maintained the following work rules for employees:

  • “Reporting persons and those who are interviewed are expected to maintain confidentiality regarding these investigations.”
  • “The following list . . . are examples of behaviors that . . . may lead to disciplinary action, up to and including termination . . . . Refusing to courteously cooperate in any company investigation. This includes, but is not limited to, unauthorized discussion of investigation or interview with other team members . . . .”

The Board majority overruled the Banner Estrella standard, in part, for its failure “to consider the importance of confidentiality assurances to both employers and employees during an ongoing investigation.”

Open Question on Investigatory Confidentiality Rules

The NLRB’s 2019 Unique Thrift Store decision didn’t actually determine whether the above rules are lawful. The Board withheld ultimate judgment in that regard because the rules themselves weren’t clearly limited to the duration of an investigation. In other words, they arguably required employees to keep quiet even after the company had completed its investigation.

The Board did not feel it had enough information to evaluate whether Unique Thrift Store had sufficient justification for requiring post-investigation confidentiality. So, it sent the case back down for further proceedings regarding that question.

Impact on Employers

Under this new ruling, companies can go back to directing employees to maintain confidentiality during an investigation. They can generally implement and enforce written rules to that effect. But they should be careful in the wording of such rules and directives. Requiring employees to stay silent even after an investigation has concluded may be more problematic. In that situation, your company should evaluate the specific circumstances and, ideally, consult with an experienced labor attorney.

Receive more updates on labor and employment law from Horton Law PLLC. Follow us on LinkedIn or subscribe to our free email newsletter.

Click for the full decision in:

Apogee Retail LLC d/b/a Unique Thrift Store, 368 NLRB No. 144 (2019)

Banner Health System d/b/a Banner Estrella Medical Center, 362 NLRB 1108 (2015)

FLSA Regular Rate

U.S. DOL Clarifies FLSA Regular Rate

For the first time in over 50 years, the U.S. Department of Labor updated its interpretation of “regular rate of pay” under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The new DOL rule takes effective January 15, 2020. The changes address new, more complicated perks and benefits. These include wellness plans, fitness classes, nutrition classes, and smoking cessation classes. The new rule will make it less costly for employers to provide additional benefits to employees. This, in turn, may increase workplace morale and employee retention.

The FLSA Regular Rate

The Fair Labor Standards Act is the federal law that establishes minimum wage, overtime pay, recordkeeping, and child labor standards. The FLSA covers most employees in the private sector and federal, state, and local governments.

Under the FLSA, an employee is eligible for minimum wage and overtime unless they qualify for a statutory exemption.

The employer must pay “non-exempt” employees at least minimum wage and compensate them for overtime at a premium rate of 1.5 multiplied by the employee’s “regular rate of pay” for all hours worked over 40 in a “workweek.”

Under current regulations, the “regular rate of pay” includes all remuneration for employment paid to or on behalf of an employee for hours worked, except for specific categories that were excluded under the FLSA. This “regular rate” includes the hourly wages and salaries for non-exempt employees, most bonuses, shift differential pay, on-call pay, and commission payments. The regular rate of pay is generally calculated by adding the employee’s includible compensation each week and dividing it by the number of hours worked within the workweek.

For more details on performing the FLSA regular rate calculation, read Calculating the Overtime ‘Regular Rate’.

New Rule on Regular Rate of Pay

The new rule clarifies that the following perks may be excluded from the calculation of an employee’s regular rate of pay, effective January 15, 2020:

  • The cost of providing parking benefits, wellness programs, onsite specialist treatments, gym access, and fitness classes, employee discount on retail goods and services, certain tuition benefits and adoption assistance;
  • Payment for unused paid leave, including paid sick leave and paid time off;
  • Certain penalties incurred by employees under state and local scheduling leave laws;
  • Business expense reimbursement for items such as cellphone plans, credentialing exam fee, organization membership dues and travel expenses that don’t exceed the maximum travel reimbursement under the Federal Travel Regulation system or the optional IRS substantiation amounts for certain travel expenses;
  • Certain sign-on and longevity bonuses;
  • Complimentary office coffee and snacks;
  • Discretionary bonuses (the DOL noted that the label given to a bonus doesn’t determine whether the bonus is discretionary); and
  • Contributions to benefit plans for accidents, unemployment, legal services, and other events that could cause financial hardship or expense in the future.

The DOL has also expanded the circumstances where employers can exclude call-back pay from the regular rate. Such payments no longer must go into the regular rate unless they are scheduled and prearranged.

Regular Rate Pitfalls

Overtime Must Be Calculated Weekly

Under the FLSA, an employer is responsible for determining the official workweek. Employers have considerable leeway in doing so. However, the workweek must consist of a fixed reoccurring 168 hours that contains seven, 24-hour workdays.  The workweek and workday start and end times must remain consistent unless employees receive advance notice of the changes.

Non-exempt employees must be paid overtime for all hours worked over 40 in a workweek (or as otherwise described by applicable law). Employers may not average the number of work hours worked by an employee over a two-week period, even if the employer has their payroll set up biweekly, to avoid paying overtime. For example, if an employee works 45 hours in week 1 and 35 hours in week 2, the employer may not average the hours worked over the two weeks resulting in a payment of zero overtime hours. Instead, the employee would be due 5 hours of overtime for week 1 and no overtime hours for week 2. Many employers make this mistake that could result in an extensive and expensive audit or litigation.

Employees Can’t Waive Overtime Pay

Non-exempt employees cannot waive their right to receive statutory overtime pay. This is true even for collective bargaining agreements or other written employment contracts.

Private Companies Can’t Use “Comp Time” Instead of Overtime Pay

Companies cannot provide employees with compensatory time (comp time) in exchange for payment for overtime hours worked each week. There are some exceptions to this rule for government workers.

Salaried, Non-Exempt Employees Are Still Eligible for Overtime Pay

An employer could pay a non-exempt employee a weekly salary that will represent pay for all regular hours of work. But if the employee works overtime during the workweek, the employer must pay additional premium compensation above and beyond the weekly salary for each overtime hour worked.

Example: An employee earns a weekly salary of $700 each week and works 43 hours. This employee’s regular rate of pay for this week would be $700/43=$16.28. The extra premium pay owed for the overtime hours can be determined by dividing the regular rate of pay in half. The employee should receive the normal weekly salary of $700, plus (3 hours x premium pay of $8.14) = $724.42.

State Overtime Laws

This new rule relates specifically to the FLSA. Many states have separate minimum wage and overtime laws. Employers often must satisfy both state and federal laws in this area. The “regular rate” concept may differ in some states. Therefore, be sure to consider the laws of your state in addition to the FLSA.

What Employers Should Do Next

Employers should conduct an overall audit to review what they include in their regular rate calculations. Companies using a third-party payroll provider should ask for clarification as to how overtime is calculated each week.

The FLSA is a complex law with many nuances beyond those described here. An experienced employment attorney can evaluate your pay practices and consult with you on overtime compliance. They might be able to identify alternative work schedules or payroll practices that comply with the wage and hour laws.

 

The new FLSA regular rate regulations are available here.